Languages

Supreme Court of Canada Rules Against Couple Seeking Compensation in Language Feud

Supreme Court of Canada Rules Against Couple Seeking Compensation in Language Feud

The Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) ruled that the Ottawa couple seeking compensation from Air Canada over language dispute cannot claim for damages. This case had been going on since 2009. The SCC ruled that Air Canada does not have an obligation to provide compensation for the couple who claimed that their rights were violated by the airline when the crew were not able to serve them in French on three occasions on their domestic and international flights between January and May in 2009. In 2011 the Federal Court of Canada awarded the couple $12,000 as compensation from Air Canada while the airline was asked to issue an official apology to the couple. However this judgment was overturned by the Federal Court of Appeal and gave the couple a lower compensation amount.

Michel and Lynda Thibodeau

The couple filed a total of eight complaints against the airline through the Official Languages Commission. They claimed that they did not receive service in French from the airline’s ground crew. They also filed a complaint when Michel was served Sprite instead of 7-Up by the English-speaking flight attendant in another flight. They claimed that on one occasion the announcement for the change of baggage carousel was done in English and was not repeated in French. It is to be noted that the couple are both fluent in English and French and opted to use French as their first language. Michel Thibodeau is a French-language rights crusader.

Earlier court proceedings

In the early days of the case hearings in court, Air Canada admitted they committed four breaches of the Official Languages Act. And that they did not have bilingual flight attendants during the times that the Thibodeaus flew with the airline in 2009. They also admitted that the weather announcement and flight arrival was done by the pilot in English and no translations were provided.

Air Canada’s position

According to Air Canada, they accept that the complaints filed by the couple were legitimate at that time, but also pointed out that the Thibodeaus did not suffer any damage, thus they should not be made to pay. The couple was seeking $525, 000 in punitive damages.

The Federal Court of Appeal agreed with the position the airline presented and reduced the amount that the court initially ordered the airline company to pay. It was then that the Official Language Commissioner brought the case to the Supreme Court on behalf of the couple.

Supreme Court ruling

The Supreme Court of Canada heard the case and issued its ruling last Tuesday. While their rights were violated for not receiving any service from the airline company in French, the court, in a five-two vote ruled that their complaints do not merit any monetary reward for damages. SCC Justice Thomas Cromwell said that according to the 1999 Montreal Convention, payment by international carriers for damages are only permitted in case of delay, loss of luggage, injury or death. There were no conditions indicated in the international treaty that applied to the Thibodeaus.

Image Copyright: josefpittner / 123RF Stock Photo

Comment Below
Languages

More in Languages

Sign Language South Africa

Will Sign Language Become The 12th Official Language of South Africa?

Christina CombenMarch 9, 2017
Merit-Based Immigration System

Arizona Bill Plans to Have Insurance Contracts in English Prevail

Bernadine RacomaFebruary 13, 2017
Austronesian Languages

20 Living Languages Still Exist in Taiwan

Bernadine RacomaFebruary 3, 2017
Canadian PM Justin Trudeau

Canadian PM Justin Trudeau Receives Formal Language Complaints

Bernadine RacomaJanuary 20, 2017
45568731 - machu picchu illuminated by the last sunlight. the inca's city is the most visited travel destination in peru. one person sitting in contemplation.

First Use of Quechua Language in Peruvian News

Bernadine RacomaDecember 19, 2016
44876121 - waving flags of eu and uk on flagpole, on blue sky background.

Foreign Language Skills Vital to the UK After Brexit

Bernadine RacomaNovember 25, 2016
justin_trudeau_2016

Canadian Government to Review Official Languages Act Regulations

Bernadine RacomaNovember 18, 2016
Learning American Sign Language

Best Universities for Learning American Sign Language Interpreting Announced

Christina CombenNovember 10, 2016
The Yiddish Language

The Yiddish Language Gets an Update for a New Era

Christina CombenNovember 2, 2016

Day News Corporation

415 Madison Avenue, 15th Floor, New York City, NY 10017

(212) 537-6123

Latest Tweets

DayNewsCo @DayNewsCo

Could not authenticate you.